Kill Team’s Punishing weapon rule is one of the most tactically potent special rules in the game. While it only activates under specific conditions, the advantages it grants during firefight sequences turning failed dice into successes when a critical is scored can dramatically swing engagements. Whether you’re building a strategy around brutal offensive efficiency or crafting a specialist-heavy roster, understanding Punishing unlocks powerful synergies. Here’s an indepth look at how the rule works, how best to use it, and when it matters most in Kill Team missions.
What Is the Punishing Rule?
Punishing is a weapon or operative rule that activates when you retain one or more critical successes on an attack roll. If that condition is met, you may convert one failed die into a normal success instead of discarding it. This bonus allows weapons with otherwise moderate reliability to perform exceptionally well in highstakes firefights.
For example, a weapon with two attack dice that scores one crit and one fail becomes two hits: one from the crit and one from the converted fail. That’s notable damage for even lightly armed operatives.
How Punishing Works in Practice
Mechanics and Timing
- You roll attack dice based on the weapon profile.
- Determine hits (including crits) relative to your Weapon Skill or Ballistic Skill.
- If at least one crit is retained, apply the Punishing rule turn one fail into a hit.
- Total successes are then compared to defender’s defence dice as normal.
Punishing only allows conversion of a single die per attack, but across several turns and multiple sharpshooters, the cumulative effect becomes substantial.
Combining with Other Rules
Punishing can stack or work in tandem with other weapon rules like Severe or Rending but order matters. If you already gain a crit through Severe, Punishing can’t retroactively upgrade another success. Community discussion confirms that Severe can apply before Punishing if both are present but timing and rule precedence are central.
Which Operatives and Strategies Best Use Punishing?
Teams That Benefit Most
- Adeptus Arbites (Exaction Squad): With their Marked for Justice strategic gambit, shooting at your designated mark grants Punishing on all Exaction Squad weapons, making them exceptionally effective against high-value targets.
- MB3 Recon Drone weapons: Some versions include Punishing alongside Ceaseless, enabling rerolls of ones and die conversions particularly deadly in steady suppressive fire.
Ideal Combat Role
Punishing works best with weapons that fire multiple dice per attack or enemy-savvy builds targeting key operatives. Precision fire becomes more consistent, effective, and less reliant on luck great for thinning priority threats or winning firefights.
How to Leverage Punishing Effectively
Loadout Synergy
- If your weapon also has Ceaseless, you can reroll ones to attempt more crits, which in turn activate Punishing.
- Combine with Severe on weapons like bolt rifles Severe creates a guaranteed crit if none are rolled, enabling the Punishing conversion.
Tactical Timing
Deploy Punishingequipped operatives at mid-range or chokepoints where accuracy matters most. Using the Marked for Justice gambit early in the turning point guarantees Punishing applies to multiple engagements that turn.
Target Priority
Focus Punishing shots on enemy Specialists or highvalue targets where every wound matters. The consistency of damage can flip early firefight momentum, especially in games with limited model pools or single squads.
Potential Drawbacks and Limitations
While powerful, Punishing does have limits:
- It only converts one failed die per attack, so overly reliant on crits for full effectiveness.
- Noncrit-heavy builds may never trigger its benefit, reducing reliability.
- Combines poorly with weapons firing only 1 die or low Weapon Skill operatives.
Effective use often requires predictable, controlled conditions where your mark remains available and attack bonuses stack reliably.
Alternative vs. Complementary Rules
Punishing vs. Rending and Severe
- Rending: Converts a normal hit into a crit if you scored any crits. Works well with highdice weapons.
- Severe: If you retain no crits, you may convert a normal success into a crit.
- Punishing: Converts a fail into a normal hit only after already scoring a crit.
Rending and Severe help stack your successes upward; Punishing helps salvage failures. Together they can create highreliability profiles that turn average rolls into meaningful results.
Punishing vs. Ceaseless
Ceaseless allows rerolls of any dice that show a 1, reducing auto-fail thresholds. When paired with Punishing, rerolls that yield crits dramatically boost consistency and opening up chances to convert fails in the same roll.
Example Unit Builds Featuring Punishing
Exaction Squad with ‘Marked for Justice’
Use the strategic gambit to mark a high-value enemy, then have multiple Exaction operatives fire at it with Punishing-equipped weapons. Each shot benefits throughout the turning point, making stacking wounds likely and consistent.
MWB Drone with Burst Cannon
This drone may come equipped with Burst Cannon that has Ceaseless and Punishing. High-output bursts with rerolls and fail conversions lets it clear small squads or finish weakened models reliably.
Summary
Punishing may look like a simple rule, but in Kill Team it defines precision, consistency, and the ability to punch above your dice pool. By turning failures into successes after scoring crits, it transforms highroll operations into topperforming fire teams. It synergizes best with Ceaseless, Severe, and Rending rules, or in strategic gambits like Marked for Justice. If you value accuracy under fire and want a dependable offensive edge, building your Kill Team around Punishing-equipped operatives is a sound strategy.
The Punishing rule rewards players who build for critical success synergy and tactical consistency. Whether attached to elite Arbites operatives using strategic Ploys, or drones outfitted with burst fire profiles, it offers a reliable conversion mechanic that transforms average rolls into gamedefining moments. When used with complementary rules or gambits, Punishing becomes a key part of an aggressive killteam strategy turning small dice pools into impactful and repeatable firepower. If you want lethal reliability and smart synergy in your roster, then mastering Punishing is essential.
: